Vinesh Phogat appeal accepted by CAS, hearing today with Harish Salve as lawyer

Vinesh Phogat appeal accepted by CAS, hearing today with Harish Salve as lawyer

Paris, France – In a significant development at the Paris Olympics 2024, Indian wrestler Vinesh Phogat’s appeal against her disqualification has been accepted by the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) in Switzerland. The hearing, which will take place at 9:30 AM in Paris (1 PM IST), marks a crucial moment in what has been an emotional and controversial journey for the Indian wrestling star. Vinesh, represented by former Solicitor General of India Harish Salve, seeks to overturn the decision that barred her from competing in the gold medal bout, and instead be awarded a joint silver medal.

The Controversy: Vinesh Phogat’s Disqualification

A Day of Triumph Turned to Despair

On August 6, Vinesh Phogat stood on the cusp of Olympic glory after winning three consecutive bouts in the women’s 50kg wrestling category. She had weighed in at 49.9kg on the morning of her first match, and after a grueling day of competition, secured her spot in the final. However, the triumph was short-lived. By the end of the day, her weight had increased to 52.7kg, which, according to her team, was a necessary part of her recovery process—hydrating and eating after intense physical exertion.

Unfortunately, on the morning of her gold medal bout, Vinesh weighed in at 50.1kg, just 100 grams over the weight limit. According to the stringent rules set by United World Wrestling (UWW), this led to her disqualification, much to the dismay of her supporters and the entire Indian sporting community.

The Immediate Fallout: A Night of Desperation

Vinesh’s disqualification sent shockwaves across the Olympic village and beyond. After the initial weigh-in, Vinesh and her team undertook drastic measures to bring her weight down to the required limit. Despite their best efforts, the scales read 50.1kg—a mere 100 grams over the limit. The disqualification was not just a personal blow to Vinesh, but a significant setback for Indian wrestling at the Olympics.

The disqualification allowed Yusneylys Guzman Lopez of Cuba, whom Vinesh had defeated in the semifinals, to step into the gold medal bout. Sarah Hildebrandt of the USA eventually won the bout, leaving Vinesh to appeal for a joint silver medal—a final attempt to salvage something from what had been a heart-wrenching experience.

The Grounds for Appeal: A Fight for Justice

A Question of Fairness and Recovery

Vinesh’s appeal to CAS is grounded in the argument that her initial weight was within the legal limit, and that her subsequent increase in weight was a natural and necessary part of recovery after intense competition. Her team argues that the 100 grams over the limit should not be viewed as an attempt to gain an unfair advantage but rather as a physiological need for recovery.

“Vinesh won three bouts on August 6 with her weight within the limit, and therefore her entry to the final was legal,” her appeal states. The argument further contends that after those bouts, Vinesh needed to hydrate and consume sufficient nutrition to allow her body to recover, a standard practice for athletes after high-level competition. Her team is seeking to challenge the application of the rules, arguing that they did not account for the natural fluctuations in an athlete’s weight following such a taxing day.

Harish Salve Steps In

To bolster her case, Vinesh has enlisted the services of Harish Salve, one of India’s most prominent legal minds. Salve, known for his expertise in constitutional law and international arbitration, has taken on the task of representing Vinesh at the CAS hearing. His involvement underscores the significance of this appeal, not just for Vinesh but for the principles of fairness and justice in sports.

The Precedent: CAS’s Role in the Paris Olympics

A Ray of Hope from Badminton

Vinesh’s appeal comes in the wake of another high-profile intervention by CAS at the Paris Olympics. In the men’s doubles badminton event, French duo Lucas Corvee and Ronan Labar were initially excluded from the draw due to an error by the Badminton World Federation (BWF). CAS intervened, allowing the French pair to compete. This decision has given Vinesh and her supporters hope that CAS may also rule in her favor, acknowledging the unique circumstances that led to her disqualification.

The Impact on Olympic Sports

CAS’s involvement in these cases highlights the critical role that the court plays in ensuring that the Olympic spirit of fairness and justice is upheld. Vinesh’s case, in particular, raises important questions about the application of rules in situations where an athlete’s health and recovery are at stake. The outcome of this appeal could set a precedent for how such cases are handled in the future, potentially leading to more nuanced regulations that account for the realities of high-level competition.

A Nation Holds Its Breath: The Emotional Toll on Vinesh Phogat

Vinesh’s Heartfelt Goodbye

Amidst the legal battle, Vinesh Phogat has been grappling with the emotional toll of her disqualification. The wrestler, who has been a beacon of hope for Indian sports, announced her retirement from wrestling on Thursday, expressing her devastation and heartbreak. In a poignant social media post, Vinesh wrote, “Ma, wrestling has won, I have lost. Please forgive me, your dreams and my courage, everything is broken. I don’t have any more strength now. Goodbye wrestling 2001-2024. I shall be indebted to you all. Forgive (me).”

Her words resonated deeply with fans and fellow athletes, many of whom took to social media to offer their support and encouragement. For Vinesh, this appeal is not just about a medal—it is about reclaiming her dignity and the pride of her career, which has been marked by resilience and excellence.

The Legacy of Vinesh Phogat

Vinesh Phogat’s career has been nothing short of remarkable. As one of India’s most successful female wrestlers, she has broken barriers and inspired a generation of young athletes. Her journey from a small village in Haryana to the grand stage of the Olympics has been filled with triumphs and challenges. The disqualification at Paris 2024 is undoubtedly one of the most difficult moments of her career, but it also presents an opportunity to cement her legacy as a fighter—both on and off the mat.

What Lies Ahead: The CAS Hearing

The Stakes Are High

As the CAS hearing approaches, the stakes could not be higher for Vinesh Phogat. A favorable ruling could see her awarded a joint silver medal, bringing some closure to what has been a deeply challenging experience. However, the outcome is uncertain, and the decision will have far-reaching implications for the interpretation of rules in Olympic sports.

A Moment of Reflection

For Vinesh, this hearing is a final stand—one last effort to ensure that her journey at the Paris Olympics is remembered not just for the controversy, but for her indomitable spirit. As she prepares for the hearing, the support of her nation and the determination that has defined her career will undoubtedly be her driving force.

 A Fight for Justice and Recognition

Vinesh Phogat’s appeal to CAS is more than just a legal battle; it is a fight for justice, recognition, and the dignity of an athlete who has given everything to her sport. As the hearing unfolds, the world will be watching closely, not just to see the outcome, but to witness the resilience of a woman who has become a symbol of strength and perseverance in Indian sports. Regardless of the outcome, Vinesh Phogat’s legacy as a trailblazer in Indian wrestling is secure, and her story will continue to inspire for generations to come.

Please check for information on the best betting sites in India – https://selectory.org/best-betting-sites/

Leave a comment